Remnants of Truth
On page 29 of Greg Egan’s excellent science fiction novel Teranesia, you will find the following passage:
Life and death were mysteries to him, but no mystery was impenetrable. The earliest attempts to understand these things, he reasoned, must have foundered against obstacles that seemed insurmountable, leaving behind failed systems of knowledge to ossify or degenerate. That was the source of religion. But someone, somewhere had always carried on the search in good faith; someone had always found the strength to keep on asking: Are the things I believe true? That was the legacy he’d claim.
I was really struck by this passage when reading it for the first time. Previously, I had always thought of most philosophies and religions as ugly warts on the face of human knowledge. The problem is not just that their teachings are incorrect: it is that they insist that they are sacred, correct, and unquestionable. Therefore, these systems of knowledge (as Egan neatly terms it) have no lasting purpose or value.
Put in the light of the quote, however, they do have significance: as discarded remnants left along the path to truth. Thinkers like Aristotle, Buddha, and Thomas Aquinas developed religious and philosophical systems which, continued by others well past their creators’ own lifetimes, became rigid and dogmatic. Because of this, the modern incarnations of these schools of thought have little value. This makes it easy to be dismissive of the men who created them, as well. But in fact their creations represent necessary steps - the inevitable branches and dead-ends - on the long and eternal road to enlightenment. These thinkers should be respected for assisting humanity down that road, not for their actual teachings.
Read more »
Defining Artistic Value
What is art? Most people define art the say same way they define pornography - “I know it when I see it.” The dictionary definition is “works produced by the conscious use of skill and creative imagination” - which tells us how it is made, but what it actually is.
First, let’s separate art into two categories: functional (e.g. architecture, graphic design, or software engineering) and pure art (e.g. painting, sculpture, or music). Items in the former category have practical purposes, which can be defined in an objective fashion. So let’s ignore that category; or at least, ignore the practical aspects of the category. A building has a functional purpose, but its aesthetic represents its pure artistic value.
Considering pure art, then, my definition is thus:
Art is an attempt by an artist to convey a concept or emotion in a non-direct fashion to an audience.
Normally, humans communicate their thoughts to each other via words, sometimes supplemented by facial expressions and gestures. This direct route of communication works well for most purposes, but not all. There are many thoughts and feelings which cannot effectively be conveyed by describing them directly. Or, perhaps they can be described, but the audience will gain only an intellectual understanding. The audience’s understanding would be much more personal and poignant if they actually feel it themselves. I can tell you “I’m angry” and you will know what I mean; but it is a more powerful thing if I create a piece of art which makes you feel angry yourself.
Read more »
The Virtues of Decentralization
Lately there has been some buzz about decentralized systems such as Peer-to-Peer (P2P) file sharing, Wiki, and the Internet itself. These systems are different from our conventional notion of organization in that there is no single seat of power. Instead, responsibility is spread amongst many nodes of matching function. These nodes are sometimes called term peers, indicating their status with regard to one another. The immediately noticeable benefit of a peer-based system is that the removal of any given node or even a large set of nodes does not necessarily cripple the entire system. In the case of the Internet, for example, service providers can come and go without the network as a whole ever going offline. Compare this to a network like CompuServe or AOL which are run by a single company; were that company to go bankrupt, the network would disappear.
So decentralized systems are a cutting-edge new approach to organization, right? Actually, they are not new at all.
It is a common and deep-seated conception that centralized authority is the best and most prevalent system of organization. Indeed, even the word “organization” (as a noun) brings to mind corporations, governments, and the military - all of which are typically arranged in a hierarchy, with power flowing from top to bottom. At the top of this power pyramid you will find a single person: the CEO, President, Commander in Chief, or King. Unlike a decentralized system, taking out the top of the pyramid cripples or even destroys the entire organization.
Read more »