Helping the Poor
Arnold Kling tackles some problems with a welfare-state approach to providing aid to the poor. Some choice clips:
“Government programs persist not because they help to alleviate social problems but because they develop political constituencies. Thus, we have a food stamp program, when the number one nutritional problem among the poor appears to be obesity. I am not saying that I don’t think that poor people need help obtaining food. But a program that was focused on poor people rather than as an indirect way to aid the farming constituency would probably operate rather differently than our existing food stamp program. With government, political goals inevitably interfere with what from an idealistic perspective would be the “public good” intent of a program.”
“Charitable organizations are better than government as a source of aid. First, it is easier for donors to hold charitable organizations accountable than it is for taxpayers to hold government accountable. A failed government program can go on forever. An ineffective charity has a more difficult time obtaining funding.”
“Those organizations that work directly with poor people stand a better chance of learning how to meet their needs than people who lobby in Washington on behalf of the poor.”
“Charitable organizations are better suited to dealing with the pathology of poverty. When people get checks from the government, they tend to think of this as an entitlement. They are getting money in exchange for doing nothing. They learn that this is how you get money — you take it from others. Taking money from others is what criminals do. Productive people get money from other people by exchanging something of value.”
Omit Needless Words
Grammar. Is there any single word more likely to evoke a yawn or perhaps a groan? The apparently arbitrary collection of nonsensical rules for sentence construction has long been the bane of every schoolchild. I can only imagine that, 30,000 years ago or so, prehistoric boys clad in animal skins rolled their eyes as their elders drilled rules like “Ugh after Grunt, except before Oogh.”
I, like pretty much everyone else, grew up believing that the rules of grammar were indeed completely arbitrary, existing for no other purpose than to torture children. Not long ago, I decided to put aside my loathing for the subject and finally learn good grammar.
Imagine my shock when I discovered that the rules aren’t arbitrary at all. Instead they are carefully assembled to serve a singular purpose: maximizing the effectiveness of human communication.
Woah.
Read more »
Faith, the Root of All Evil
In our modern world of tolerance, it is sometimes said that that science and faith can coexist. Richard Dawkins boldly challenges that notion in two 45 minute video segments titled The Root of All Evil. His approach is even-handed but pulls no punches, as he claims that blind faith is dangerous in any form (not just Islam). I love part 1’s closing line:
“We are all atheists about most of the gods that societies have ever believed in. Some of us just go one god further.”
Elephant’s Dream
Elephant’s Dream is an impressive 3D short. It was created entirely using open source tools (primarily Blender and Gimp - the very same tools I used to create the cover for my last album). It’s released under the Creative Commons license, which means you can share it with your friends or even modify it - completely free from hassle by the MPAA.
What really astonishes me about this film is the quality of its imagery. I would say that the graphics in this are better than Pixar movies from just a few years back.
Science Has Better Magic
Despite living in the Age of Reason, human fascination with mysticism remains as strong as ever. Mysticism comes in many forms: organized religion, new age spirituality, faith healing, tarot cards, magnet healing, hypnosis, astrology, alien abduction, telekinesis, ESP. What they all have in common is a lack of tangible effects, compensated for by strong emotional effects on their believers.
Without fail, all forms of mysticism promise some sort of magic. Tarot cards tell your future. Faith healers send your cancer into remission. The Christian god answers your prayers like some kind of cosmic Santa Claus. In every single case, the benefits promised are always vague and untestable. None of these things ever produce any result except making their believers feel spooky.
Why can’t a faith healer heal a broken leg or staunch the bleeding on a deep cut? Why is it always a hard-to-diagnose disease like cancer which goes in and out of remission on its own anyway?
Read more »
A Sad Lunch
Anthony Lane reviews the Da Vinci Code with a biting wit that aligns closely with my own thoughts on this work of pop fiction.
“There has been much debate over Dan Brown’s novel ever since it was published, in 2003, but no question has been more contentious than this: if a person of sound mind begins reading the book at ten o’clock in the morning, at what time will he or she come to the realization that it is unmitigated junk? The answer, in my case, was 10:00.03, shortly after I read the opening sentence: “Renowned curator Jacques Saunière staggered through the vaulted archway of the museum’s Grand Gallery.” With that one word, “renowned,” Brown proves that he hails from the school of elbow-joggers - nervy, worrisome authors who can’t stop shoving us along with jabs of information and opinion that we don’t yet require. (Buried far below this tic is an author’s fear that his command of basic, unadorned English will not do the job; in the case of Brown, he’s right.) You could dismiss that first stumble as a blip, but consider this, discovered on a random skim through the book: “Prominent New York editor Jonas Faukman tugged nervously at his goatee.” What is more, he does so over “a half-eaten power lunch,” one of the saddest phrases I have ever heard.”