Cognitive Surplus
“If I had to pick the critical technology for the 20th century, the bit of social lubricant without which the wheels would’ve come off the whole enterprise, I’d say it was the sitcom. Starting with the Second World War a whole series of things happened–rising GDP per capita, rising educational attainment, rising life expectancy and, critically, a rising number of people who were working five-day work weeks. For the first time, society forced onto an enormous number of its citizens the requirement to manage something they had never had to manage before–free time.
[…]
I was being interviewed by a TV producer [who asked about Wikipedia]. ‘Where do people find the time?’ That was her question. And I just kind of snapped. And I said, ‘No one who works in TV gets to ask that question. You know where the time comes from. It comes from the cognitive surplus you’ve been masking for 50 years.’”
From Gin, Television, and Social Surplus by Clay Shirky
[citation needed]
Schools
I always enjoy Bob Cringley’s articles, but when he speaks of how schools are outdated, I’m especially impressed. Paul Graham has said that high schools are basically prisons, and I agree with that, but Cringley takes it further: all schools, from kindergarden straight up through med school, follow a model that is increasingly out of sync with the modern world. He gives some compelling arguments as to why schools, as we know them today, will be gone completely in the next decade or so.
One of his key points is that “we’re moving from a knowledge economy to a search economy.” This is a pithy and less threatening way of stating the hard truth: that values held dear by traditional education are no longer useful. This is going to be very hard for people to let go of. Expect a lot of bitterness and fighting from those with their identities, lives, and possibly paychecks intimately tied to the industry and culture of traditional education.
But I for one couldn’t be happier to see scholastic institutions fade away. I didn’t get a lick of value from my time spent in school, other than social side-effects like learning how to deal with the schoolyard bully or how to pass notes in class undetected. Only once school ended was my time freed up to spend on actual learning. I can only imagine how much further along I would be in life now if I could have started learning 20 years earlier.
Cringely’s article has two subsequent followups that expand on his ideas, and all three are also available as podcasts. Highly recommended.
Honk If You Hate Honking
People around here love to honk. I used to honk, very occasionally, while driving in LA. In almost all cases it was to alert someone that they were causing an obstruction, if it seemed like they were unaware of it. This is not supposed to be unfriendly. I think we’ve all done it - you’re digging around under the seat for something at a red light, the light turns green, and you fail to notice. After a brief waiting period (say, 5 or 10 seconds), a honk to alert you to the situation from the driver behind you is, to my mind, perfectly reasonable.
Since coming to SF, I’ve stopped using my horn altogether, as a backlash to what to me seems to be massively gratuitous use.
The use of honking here seems similar to my former purpose: alerting someone to an obstacle that they are causing. But the thing is, streets here are a veritable obstacle course nearly all of the time. Taxis pulling over to pick up fares. Riders on bikes and motorcycles. Lots of pedestrians, and rarely do they pay much attention to traffic signals. People looking for parking, or trying to parallel park in a space that’s just a tad too small (and they all are). Delivery trucks pulled over with their hazards on, because there’s no place to park them while making the delivery. Muni buses, tour buses, cable cars, and trains. And here and there, a newbie to driving in the city, who finds themselves constantly confused by the labyrinthine tangle of one-way streets and no-turn intersections. (e.g., me about eight months ago.)
In this environment, honking rarely serves a useful purpose. There’s cars and people and buses and bikes everywhere you look, all weaving in and out between one another; so when someone honks, it’s pretty much impossible to tell what they are honking about, if it is directed at you, and if so what you should do. It just adds more distractions to the chaotic mess. Which leads me to believe that in fact it isn’t about obstruction alerts anymore, but is just a way for people to vent.
This city has many charms, but this little bit of the local culture is really quite unpleasant.
Programmed For Scarcity
Humans are so prone to becoming information junkies:
“Because at one time we never knew when the next saber-toothed tiger might come along for food, it made sense to pack on the calories whenever we chanced upon them. That’s not much help in today’s world of snack aisles and super sizes. […] We are programmed for scarcity and can’t dial back when something is abundant.”