Popes, Presidents, and Zombies
Some time ago, I watched a documentary about the Vatican, which gave a peek at the highly ritualistic lifestyle of the pope. One aspect in particular jumped out at me: once elected, every single moment of the pope’s life from that day forward is planned. He never has a moment to himself, or some free time to sit and think. He can’t pursue his own interests or take a vacation. In short, he is always the pope, for every minute between election and death.
This seemed to explain something I had always noticed, when watching video footage of the guy. He seems lifeless. An animated corpus, moving through a series of motions and activities predefined long before, but with no inner passion or spirit of his own.
And it makes sense - I think we would all react that way, given a guided lifestyle like his. Always on display, always performing a role. Every moment is a potential photo-op. (Seriously: the guy has his own photographer that follows him around all day, snapping pictures of nearly every waking moment.)
I guess it just wouldn’t do to have the pope ever caught scratching his ass, or making a funny face while laughing at a joke, or displaying the least bit of emotion about his own life or circumstance. What can one do, when one must constantly suppress their thoughts, feelings, and desires, 24 hours a day? I think those thoughts and feelings simply become lost. The best way to suppress them is never to have them in the first place.
It also strikes me that this is true, to a lesser degree, with US presidents. People get so passionate about hating Bush, and they seem to hold it against him personally. But maybe Bush is like the pope: a shell, a puppet held up to be a face for a phenomenon much larger than any one person. What does the president think about any given topic? I don’t think it matters. His job isn’t to think. He’s a symbol, a flag, an avatar for the thoughts and feelings of an entire nation, as expressed through the democratic process. What he thinks or feels doesn’t really matter. He’s like a little girl’s doll: she imagines the doll has whatever thoughts or feelings she wants to project onto it.
Things aren’t as hopeless for presidents; they can be people again one day. I remember Clinton seeming like this plastic face, never displaying a bit of humanity that I could spot. Now, years later, I see him occasionally on the Daily Show or elsewhere and he comes across as an intelligent, thoughtful human being with emotions just like anyone else. I find it kind of shocking, because I associate that face with the lifeless puppet of his presidential term.
It’s not too surprising that Clinton is a smart guy. You don’t really get to be president by being an idiot. Despite what people think about Bush, he’s probably extremely intelligent, educated, and hard-working. But you’d never know it from a presidential term. And it’s not his fault: the job robs its holder of their soul. Anyone who accepts the office of president makes the sacrifice: turn yourself into an empty, soulless vessel, so that millions of others can fill you up with whatever they want you to be.
February 27th, 2007 10:59 am
The soul? I thought you didn’t believe in such things? What do you mean by the term? Where do you think the power for self-determination comes from?
February 27th, 2007 12:16 pm
That being the case, I think it is even more impressive that he formally declared the church erred in condemning Galileo.
February 28th, 2007 1:37 am
Brendan -
Woah, those are some big questions. Let’s see if I can answer them with anything resembling succinctness.
What I mean by the term “soul” is the emergent property of the human brain: intellect, emotion, and sentience.
Assuming that by self-determination you mean the ability to chose one’s own fate, I would say that this is also an emergent property of the structure of our brains, i.e. a part of (or similar concept to) the soul. There is the question of how we can be truly free agents if our behavior is potentially deterministic, emerging from our physical natures. The best answer I’ve found to this question can be read in The Science of Good and Evil by Michael Shermer.