Tradition

Critical Thinking by Adam on 2009-01-21 04:40

“Tradition means beliefs handed down from grandparent to parent to child, and so on. Or from books handed down through the centuries. Traditional beliefs often start from almost nothing; perhaps somebody just makes them up originally, like the stories about Thor and Zeus. But after they’ve been handed down over some centuries, the mere fact that they are so old makes them seem special. People believe things simply because people have believed the same thing over the centuries.”

Dawkins is up to his old tricks.

4 comments per 'Tradition'

  1. Dave says:

    This a fantastic article (or letter?).

    However, I do think that for traditions to withstand the test of time, they *usually* either have to be mostly neutral, or correct guesses (at least for some large portion of the time they have been held).

    It’s important to distinguish between the fact that some traditions are traditions because they do work to some extent, and the fact that *being* a tradition does not in and of itself mean it *will* work.

    In propositional logic:
    IF (X works) => becomes TraditionX

    NOT EQUAL TO

    IF (TraditionX exists) => (X must work)

    The reverse implication is one of the more common logical fallacies that the average person tends to make.

  2. Dave says:

    Oh one more thing…

    Just because a tradition *works* to some extent does not mean that better ways haven’t come along.

    That is the risk of holding a tradition just because it’s a tradition.

    I’m sure you know this, but this is an important point for people to understand if they tend to believe traditions.

  3. online erectile dysfunction prescription says:

    online erectile dysfunction prescription

    Adam @ Dusk » Tradition

  4. online erectile dysfunction prescription says:

    online erectile dysfunction prescription

    Adam @ Dusk » Tradition

Post a comment

Enter your comment (some HTML allowed)