Economic Growth: A Fable
Do you believe that economic growth is good or bad?
Most people, asked this question, will say “good.” This is at odds, however, with how they actually react to the effects of economic growth. Why? My guess is because the most apparent effect to individuals is loss of employment.
Although I certainly don’t think that a person losing their job is a good thing, in the context of economic growth it is a part of a larger phenomenon that is extremely beneficial to society as whole. Those benefits eventually reach the temporarily unemployed individual, but they are subtle and spread out over time. The event which is felt and remembered most poignantly is the unexpected layoff.
Like most of my blog entries, paragraph three seems to be where I get into definitions. So here goes: Economic growth is an increase in productivity. If your employer were to give you a raise of an additional $1 per hour, that could be considered personal economic growth. You aren’t working more hours, or working any harder during those hours; but you are producing more - getting more output - for the same input of time and energy.
On the other hand, if you took on a second job so that you could have some extra income, this would not be considered economic growth. You are producing more output, true, but you are also inputing more time and energy. The total input-to-output ratio has not changed. Economic growth is getting more bang for your buck, more benefit for time invested. A second job at same hourly rate has the same amount of benefit per hour; there is no change in the ratio there.
Of course the term economic growth is not usually applied to individuals, but instead to nations or other geographic regions. In this case the productivity measured is not money earned by individuals; it is total value of the goods and services produced by an entire economy. The subject rapidly gets very complex even considering just a small area such as a single city. We must examine more than just what is being produced; there is also how those goods and services are exchanged, transported, and consumed.
The most common and direct cause of economic growth is new technology. At some point you may have heard someone complaining about about losing their job, having been replaced by a robot (say, on an assembly line) or a computer (for example, a bank teller laid off due to the installation of more ATMs). Although certainly an unhappy event for the person who lost their job, an understanding of the relationship between new technology, higher productivity, and economic growth may put things into a different light.
So in that spirit, I now present a short fable to demystify the meaning and effects of economic growth.
Welcome to Growland
In the village of Growland, all 100 adult, able-bodied citizens work full time. Every single person in the village has the same job: farming. Tilling, planting, and harvesting the crops is so time-consuming that unless everyone works full time, there will not be enough food to go around. (This is called “subsistence farming.”)
The populace of Growland is quite happy. They are all gainfully employed and relatively well-fed. Life is good.
One day, a traveler visits the town. He brings with him a strange contraption which he calls a “plow.” When pulled by an ox which is guided by a farmer, the plow allows fields to be tilled in half as much time.
At first, the Growlanders are thrilled with this new technology. But it doesn’t take long for them to realize that something has gone horribly wrong. Since all of the village’s fields can be worked by half as many people as before, this means that fully half of their workforce - 50 people - are no longer employed!
This causes much confusion and anger among the community. With only half the population working, there is a strong sense of inequity among the citizens. The fifty people who are unemployed no longer have any way of producing food, and must rely on charity from the other half in order to keep themselves fed. The employed people, on the other hand, become resentful of the easy lives of the unemployed. They wonder: why should I break my back all day long, and then give up half what I produce to someone who does absolutely no work at all?
After weeks of heated debate in the village, many begin to call for getting rid of the plows and pretending that the technology had never come to Growland. This view is particularly popular among the village’s elders, who proclaim that tilling the land by hand is “the way it’s always been.”
One day, one of the village’s unemployed, a young man by the name of Trepren, decides to spend some of his (now copious) free time improving his hut. The Growlanders have always lived in very crude mud-and-thatch huts, which are in a constant state of disrepair since everyone is always too busy working the fields to fix them. Trepren remakes his roof with a double-thick layer of fresh thatch, patches up holes in the wall, and adds an extra layer of mud to the outer wall to increase its sturdiness and insulation.
When the cold season comes, Trepren’s friends are amazed when they visit his hut. Its thicker roof and walls keep it much warmer inside than their own domiciles. One friend, a young woman named Consuma, is one of the fifty still employed as a farmer. She is very interested in having Trepren fix up her own hut the same way, and so she offers to give him a month’s supply of food in exchange for the job. Trepren agrees and immediately sets to work improving her hut.
Witnessing Consuma and Trepren’s arrangement, other employed villagers - who also have a surplus of food and desire warmer huts - make the same offer to Trepren. Before long Trepren cannot keep up with the demand for improvements and ongoing repairs of all fifty huts. He takes on a few assistants from the unemployed portion of the population, training them to use the techniques he has developed and giving them a share of the food he earns in exchange.
Before long, the entire population is working again. Fifty of them are working as farmers, using the plow, and fifty work maintaining huts. Everyone is well-fed and gainfully employed, just as before, but now everyone has a nice, cozy hut as well. Life is good again - in fact, better than before. The strife that the plow initially brought is forgotten. A generation passes.
One day, a traveler visits the town. She brings with her a strange square device called a “cast.” When mud is poured into the cast and allowed to dry, it forms what she calls a “brick.” These bricks can be used to build much sturdier and more attractive huts than the traditional method. What’s more, by using many casts at once, the construction of a new hut can be completed very rapidly. Even ongoing maintenance of the huts is easier, since individual bricks can be replaced as they weather or get damaged.
At first, the Growlander hutbuilders are thrilled with this new technology. But it doesn’t take long for them to realize that something has gone horribly wrong. Since the huts can now be built and maintained with less work, this requires fewer hutbuilders to maintain the same number of huts. Half the hutbuilding workforce - 25 people - are no longer employed!
This causes much confusion, anger, and resentment among the people who are put out of work.
After weeks of heated debate among the hutbuilders, many begin to call for getting rid of the casts and pretending that the technology had never come to Growland. This view is particularly popular among the elder hutbuilders, who proclaim that building huts by hand is “the way it’s always been.”
Trepren’s daughter, Enny, remembers the tale of how her father founded the Growland hutbuilding industry. As one of the newly unemployed, she is inspired to start her own business. Her father agrees to provide investment capital, in the form of six months supply of food. She founds a small theater troupe, which provides entertainment in the form of dramatic plays to the Growland population. She hires former hutbuilders, now unemployed, to write scripts, build sets, and act in the productions.
The village is thrilled and delighted by the availability of nighttime entertainment, and gladly pay a small portion of their food surplus to attend. As the theater grows in popularity, Enny begins hiring every single available person to keep up with demand. And before long, the entire population is working again.
Fifty of them are working as farmers, using the plow. Twenty-five of them are working maintaining huts, using casts. And the last twenty-five work in the theater, performing for the hard-working farmers and hutbuilders. Everyone is well-fed, lives in a cozy hut, and enjoys the luxury of frequent entertainment. Life is good again - in fact, better than before. The strife that the cast initially brought is forgotten. A generation passes.
One day, a traveler visits the town…
I should hope that the moral of my little tale is self-evident, but I’m in an expository mood, so let me sum up. Economic growth is an increase in productivity, which means fewer people are needed to produce the same output. The “fewer people” bit is the part that people don’t like, because this means layoffs and unemployment. But by freeing up a portion of the population to pursue other ventures, society as a whole has a chance to grow and improve. Modern economies invent or import new technology constantly, so it follows that there is also a constant turnover of workers. This is normal and expected; and despite the temporary personal difficulties it may cause in the lives of the transitioning workforce, overall it is a Good Thing.
July 27th, 2009 8:41 am
first time driver insurence vehicles amwestgroup the united kingdom navigator l
crates airship tachometer bloodstained Diocletian.
February 9th, 2014 3:09 pm
air jordan i
Adam @ Dusk ? Economic Growth: A Fable