Poor People Live Like Kings

Philosophy, Economics, Infinite Series by Adam on 2006-11-11 08:37

“People in <insert poor country here> live off of less than $1 a day.”

How often have you come across a phrase like this in a magazine or on the news? When we encounter a figure like this, we shake our heads in pity the poverty of these individuals, and give thanks for our own good fortune.

Recently I read an article which described the lifestyle of a family living in India, one of the poorest large nations on earth. The article pointed out that the family was living the exact same way that their great-grandparents had a century ago. Same farm, same farming techniques, same quantity of food, same clothing. Note that their great-grandparents were not poor; it is only the modern individuals (according to the article) who are.

Wait a minute: their lives are almost exactly the same as their ancestors, yet we call one of them poor and the other not? Why? If their lives are the same, shouldn’t they get the same label?

Poverty, it turns out, is a relative label. That makes sense. But when you stop to think about the implications of this, some really odd phenomena pop up.

For example: were the native Americans (”indians”) poor before European settlers got here? No; they lived off the land just like they always had. Life was great. But the moment Columbus set foot on the continent, suddenly they were all dirt poor. And not because of any of the harm that he and other explores would impose upon the natives through conquest or foreign disease. No, the reason was a simple matter of comparison. Europeans had horses, ships, guns, armor, cities, clocks, eyeglasses, and a million other things that made them, comparatively, much richer than the indians. So suddenly, the indians were poor - even though their circumstances hadn’t changed in the slightest.

Let’s extend this even further with a metaphor. Let’s say that tomorrow, some human travelers come back in time and arrive on our doorstep. They come out to greet the people of their past, displaying their incredible technology that grant eternal life and youth, instant teleportation to any place or time, and so forth.

Suddenly, George Soros, Bill Gates, and Donald Trump are all dirt-poor.

The future humans sadly shake their head as they read the statistic that Soros et. al. live on less than $100 million dollars per day. Seeing a figure like this, the time-travelers shake their heads in pity at the poverty of these individuals, and give thanks for their own good fortune.

Poor people today live better than kings did a few centuries ago. Go into the household of a family “living below the poverty line” and you’ll find televisions, cell phones, and an abundance of nutritious and unspoiled food. The richest king or sultan from eras past could only dream of such incredible wealth.

Perhaps most notable is the medical care. For a tiny percentage of their income, a poor person can get inoculations or cures to diseases that absolutely no amount of money could have bought even just a century ago.

So what does this mean? I’m not sure. “Poverty” as a label is obviously useful, and it’s relative nature makes sense. But it does mean that the War on Poverty (much like many “War on ?s”) can never be won, because as long as we keep raising the bar someone will still be poor.

6 comments per 'Poor People Live Like Kings'

  1. nike blazers wholesale clothes says:

    nike blazers wholesale clothes

    once you clipped a thing from using it, so therefore style over dice pressed paper which also has a card stock or else compose memory foam, a person may make attractive diamond earrings within a few minutes. although if the logo will way too big over b…

  2. longchamp pliage besace says:

    longchamp pliage besace

    http://longchampsac.lanarchinumeriquev2.fr/bagages-longchamp.htmlbagages longchamp

  3. arduino display says:

    arduino display

    Adam @ Dusk

  4. arduino display says:

    arduino display

    Adam @ Dusk

  5. how to make money online fast says:

    how to make money online fast

    Adam @ Dusk » Poor People Live Like Kings

  6. how to make money online fast says:

    how to make money online fast

    Adam @ Dusk » Poor People Live Like Kings

Post a comment

Enter your comment (some HTML allowed)