Invasion of the Meat Machines

Life, Health by Adam on 2007-01-16 01:27

Modern medical science is all about fixing what’s broken. This is a good solution when you have a direct affliction or injury: a specific infectious disease, a broken bone, a deep cut. But this is only one small part of the overall picture of human health. Keeping the body sound and healthy is much more than just stitching up the occasional wound.

I think that most people sense this subconsciously, and that’s the appeal of all the folk healing and new age practices that people spend so much time and energy on: acupuncture, crystal healing, homeopathy, herbal remedies, etc. If you’ve read my blog much you probably already know that I think all that stuff is best described as somewhere between ineffective and an outright scam. But don’t worry, this post is not yet another debunking, or more critical thinker finger-wagging. No, today I’ve got something a little different on the menu.

I’ve recently been introduced to the field of physical therapy. I, like most, thought of this as something you do after sustaining a serious injury, part of the fixing-broken-stuff expertise of medical science. So it was with surprise that I learned that the realm of physical therapy is actually much wider and more generally useful than just recovering from specific injuries.

Physical therapy (I’ll shorten it to PT from here on) regards the body as an organic machine whose parts need to be kept in good working order. There are many special considerations which apply to the-body-as-a-machine, such as the adaptable nature of its parts (both a blessing and a curse, as we’ll see later), and the function of pain as an indicator for malfunction and structural weakness.

Under the age of about 25, most people not suffering from any specific debilitating disease hardly think about their body at all. It always does what they want and never seems to complain no matter how poorly they treat it. Then, somewhere in the mid-twenties, we each experience that unpleasant realization: “Oh, I have to pay attention to my body? It’s not just an indestructible perpetual motion machine? How very inconvenient.”

The first way that we start to pay attention to our bodies are the aches and pains. Seemingly mysterious in origin, they grow in intensity and frequency as you age, until one day you’re a cranky codger, sitting on the porch complaining about your old bones. You might complain about these aches to your doctor, and he may tell you to make sure you eat enough calcium or whatever, but ultimately this is not in his domain of expertise. You don’t have any injury; nothing is broken. This is simply wear and tear.

A grim tale, no? Read on, gentle reader, for there’s hope after all.

Adaptation

Most people respond to these aches and pains by reducing their activity. Unfortunately that’s the worst thing you could possibly do. Remember how I mentioned earlier that the body’s adaptability was both a blessing and a curse? When you don’t use your parts, they decay with disuse. Ligaments tighten and muscles atrophy; then other nearby parts are forced to compensate, which puts extra strain on them and throws off the overall balance of your meat machine.

This is a place where the PT approach is notably different from the approach of other medical fields: it’s a holistic practice, meaning it takes a big-picture view of the body’s function. If you tell a doctor that your knee hurts - as I did - then they’ll focus completely on your knee, taking x-rays of it and poking at it and generally never thinking to look anywhere but where the pain is.

As my physical therapist told me, “Knees always get a bad rap, because they are positioned such that they take the strain from malfunctioning components above or below. In truth the problem is almost never in the knee itself, which is a relatively simple joint.” As it turned out, my knee hurt because it was bearing the strain of muscle imbalances and poor flexibility in my hips.

And here’s where the bad adaptability comes in. Certain muscles in my hips and legs were very weak, and some of the ligaments extremely tight. (Stretching them for the first time in my PT sessions was shockingly painful.) Because of how I exercise my lower body and because of the way I sit all day long, certain muscles had become strong, and others had become weak. This produced imbalances in the way that I moved and walked. Years of this started to take their toll on my knees.

Here’s the good news: adaptability works both ways. As soon as I started stretching out those ligaments and strengthening the weak muscles, my knee problems disappeared practically overnight. For anyone young, stretching out and doing some minor exercises a few times a day is all you need to correct a problem like this. They do have to be the right exercises and stretches, though, which I’ll go into in a moment.

Balance

Part of the problem was actually that some of my muscles were too strong. Gyms and modern exercise sensibilities are very focused on aesthetics: we’re there because of how we want to look, and only very secondarily for health reasons. And what do we see when we look in the mirror? Our front. So we tend to overexercise our fronts: for men, this is primarily pectorals, abdomen, and quadriceps. This leaves our bodies very unbalanced as the matching muscles on the reverse side - lats, back, glutes - tend to be underemphasized or even ignored completely.

Women’s exercises probably aren’t quite as bad, because they focus on weight loss, which tends to be cardiovascular, which is usually more of a full-body workout. Even so, there is still plenty of opportunity for unbalance here.

A healthy meat machine is one that has balanced strength, where the parts all share the load in a way that is appropriate to the machine’s design. When one part is compensating for another, weaker part, it tends to be doing a job that it’s not as good at, or bearing the weight at a poor angle.

Why the adaptability, anyway? Why doesn’t our body maintain all its parts perfectly, all the time? I can only speculate here, but my guess it that it’s an evolutionary mechanism. Maintaining maximal muscle mass and healthy joints all the time takes a lot of resources; if our bodies worked this way, everyone would keel over dead at the first hard winter where food was scarce. At least the resulting corpses would all be good-looking.

Stretching

Anyone who’s been an athlete or gone to the gym or whatever has often heard the mantra of stretching. Stretching is good for you; do it before you work out; do it after you work out; etc. I had made attempts at pre-workout stretching for years, but it never seemed to do any good. In fact, I was right: the stretches most people do not only don’t do any good, but may actually be harmful.

There are a few common errors which make stretching ineffective the way that most people do it:

  1. Improper form - This is the big one: a minor difference in posture or angle of the limbs can turn a perfectly good stretch into a harmful one. Many of the commonly-taught stretches are very difficult to do right, and so an even slightly sloppy execution will produce adverse effects.
  2. Not holding long enough. I used to count to 15 when stretching, and the speed at which I counted meant that it was more like 10 seconds. This is basically a waste of time. 20 - 30 seconds is ideal.
  3. Bouncing - Don’t do it; hold steady.
  4. Not going far enough - If you don’t actually feel a stretch, it’s not stretching anything.
  5. Going too far - Which just piles on the wear and tear, the very thing we were trying to counteract.

The last two points indicate that there is a middle ground which is the correct stretch distance. This distance will be different for everyone (and will change as your flexibility increases), so no one except for you can properly judge this. What you want to do is stretch far enough that you feel a good stretch, without actually feeling pain or excessive strain.

What stretches should you do? That’s a question for a physical therapist. There’s probably a set of good common ones, but explaining them inadequately is worse than no explanation at all, because you’ll end up doing them wrong. There are some online resources, like this one, but be careful - form is everything, and it’s hard to get it right without someone knowledgeable watching and guiding you as you learn the stretch.

Strength

Strength is just as important as stretching. Your muscles bear your weight, and when they can’t, the strain falls on your ligaments and bones.

When you think of strength you may think of strength training, i.e. lifting weights at the gym every third day. That’s good for building mass (which in turn provides fat-burning capability, power, and an attractive physique), but this sort of strength is not really what you need for maintaining your meat machine.

The exercises I learned as part of PT were simple and easy to do anywhere, since in most cases they required no weights or other special equipment. They focused on functional strength, that is, the ability to control your body’s movement in common situations.

Now this last point is interesting. Many or even most of the exercises people commonly do are movements that are not found anywhere else outside the gym. How often do you find yourself needing to lie on your stomach, lifting hundreds of pounds above your back using just your hamstrings? Never, that’s when - but this is one of the most common exercise machines.

My therapist made the argument: shouldn’t everyone be able to control their own body mass as they move? And so he is a fan of these sort of functional strength exercises designed to reflect how we use our bodies in regular life. Exercises like pushups, pullups, lunges, sidesteps, and shoulder presses.

I don’t intend to quit my regular weight training because, hey, everyone wants to look good. But I realize now that this serves an end toward aesthetics, physical power, and a certain amount of health benefit. Other types of exercises are necessary to keep my body limber, youthful, and able to engage in strenuous physical activity even as the effects of age set in.

Ergonomics

I spend about twelve hours a day in front of a computer. I suspect that, counting in driving, time at the office, time in movie theaters, and even time on the sofa, most of us spend the majority of our lives sitting down.

One doesn’t think much about it - sitting is easy, after all. But surprisingly, it’s much more likely to strain your body in unusual ways than standing. We didn’t evolve to spend the majority of our lives at a desk, it seems.

There’s a lot that could be said here, but let me keep it simple. When you’re sitting at a computer, sit up straight, put your feet flat on the ground, and slide your ass backward* in the chair so that your trunk is at a 90 degree angle to your thighs, your thighs are parallel with the ground, and your calves are in turn at a 90 degree angle to your thighs. Put your monitor at approximately eye height so that you’re looking straight ahead most of the time. In general, try to keep your body square to the desk. Something similar can be said for the seat adjustment in your car, sitting on your sofa for long periods, etc.

* I think I should get some kind of writer’s award for using the phrase “ass backward” correctly in a sentence without it being a hyphenated adjective.

I was surprised to learn how far away from this description my regular pose was. I had the back of my chair unlocked so that I was always sort of leaning back slightly, and my legs cocked out at funny angles to the side. My feet were never flat on the ground.

It might seem like this rigid position is less comfortable, but over the long term it will feel better. Sitting this way causes your body to use the right muscles, the ones that are strongest and best suited to bear your weight. Sitting any other way causes unnatural strain on your parts, which will accumulate with time.

The squaring thing is a really important underlying principle as well. Our bodies are symmetrical and they work best when we distribute our weight evenly. When stretching, exercising, or doing anything at all, keeping your limbs and trunk aligned in parallel and perpendicular positions (i.e., “square”) will avoid torque on your joints.

Kinesthetic Awareness

Kinesthetics or proprioception is your sense of your own body’s position. This is one of those absolutely remarkable feats that our bodies and brains perform seemingly effortlessly, to the point that we rarely ever stop to think about it. But in fact the process of sensing the exact position and orientation of each part of our body in 3-dimensional space requires a hugely complex network of nerves throughout our body, coupled with a dedicated processing center in the brain. The exact position of either of your hands, for example, requires interpreting data from your shoulder, elbow, and wrist, all of which together posses seven degrees of freedom.

Good kinesthetics is vital to performing your stretches and exercises in a way that is helpful instead of harmful. A physical therapist can stand over your shoulder and correct you when you’re learning, but on an ongoing basis you need to learn to do it yourself. For example, in most of the lower body stretches I was working on, thinking about how the hips are positioned and rotated was the difference between a successful stretch and a pointless (or harmful) one. This is something we just don’t think about much, but you need to train yourself to do it to maintain your body’s health long term.

Physical Therapy as Maintenance

We all know that preventative medicine is far more effective than treating something after it becomes a problem. Nowhere is this more true than physical therapy. Based on what I know now, I feel that everyone would be benefited from regular checkups with a physical therapist, perhaps once a year, the same as is recommended with an MD.

Unfortunately, most people don’t end up at PT unless they experience a specific injury, as I did. This problem is compounded by the fact that insurance will not pay for the therapy unless it has been prescribed by your regular doctor. I certainly feel that this is important enough that I would be willing to pay for the service directly. (Or at least, just beg my doctor for a prescription once a year.)

Here is where I went for my therapy:

Glendale Adventist Medical Center
Therapy & Wellness Center
2560 Colorado Blvd.
Eagle Rock, CA 90041
323 255 5409

The therapist I saw was Jonathan Yeh, and he rocked. You can ask for him when you make an appointment, although I got the impression that all the therapists there were very competent.

Conclusion

Regular medicine treats your body like a mechanic treats a car: they open you up, tinker with what’s inside, and send you home. Maybe on your way out the door they mention that you should avoid cholesterol or get enough exercise or eat apples or whatever. Physical therapy, by contrast, is about building good exercise habits and giving you the knowledge to keep the meat machine that is your body in good working order.

I don’t mean to suggest that physical therapy is a panacea that will guarantee that you can do backflips at 80. But I do think it’s a way to keep your body in the shape necessary to enjoy life’s physically intensive activities like hiking, dancing, and sex. I for one plan to be striding across the playa, or dancing my heart out at Jack’s ranch, for decades to come.

Post a comment

Enter your comment (some HTML allowed)