Solving World Hunger Through Enlightened Self-Interest
The Summer 2005 news bulletin from the Citizens Against Government Waste contains a letter to the editor which reads:
If, for example, farm subsidies are considered waste and are cut, then will people go hungry? What then?
America is the most prosperous nation in the history of mankind, due directly to its high level of economic freedom. It shocks me, then, to learn that one of its citizens is so blithely unaware of the function of the free market. In case the question quoted above actually seems reasonable to you, allow me to explain.
The quantity of people that go hungry in a nation is inversely proportional to the freedom of its markets. One only needs to look at the examples of history for evidence of this. The USSR had very minimal free markets and had a starving populace for most of its existence. Food shortages continue to be a huge problem in China, the largest (and arguably most successful) socialist nation in existence today. In contrast, the US has mostly free markets and is the best-fed populace on earth. In fact, Americans are so well-fed that the number one health problem facing the nation’s poor is obesity.
Folks, you know you’ve got it good when the biggest problem for the poor is too much food.
But putting aside evidence for a minute and just looking at the abstract case, you’ll see that my statement above is actually quite intuitive. Let’s take an example.
Let’s imagine that there is a drought in the area of the country where you live, such that no one can grow food locally. What happens? Simple enough: that area will import food from nearby areas. But there’s a catch: the further the food has to come, the more it costs to transport it there. (Food is tricky to transport since it is highly perishable, so therefore transportation costs tend to be high.) But if you’re starving and there is no local food available, would you be willing to pay $1.50 for an apple that normally costs $1? I’m guessing that you would. I bet you’d even be willing to pay $2 or $2.50.
If you live in a country with economic restrictions such as price caps - a common type of farm subsidy, even in the US - this greatly restricts your ability to acquire food. Even though you’re willing to pay $1.50 (or more) for that apple, the price is capped at $1. Food importers can’t afford to bring in apples from other regions, so they don’t do it. You, and everyone else in your region, is unable to purchase any apples. The food is simply not made available.
In a truly free market, importers are free to charge whatever they want. Many might think that this leads to another problem: price gouging. Instead of charging twice as much for that apple, importers might charge ten times as much. One might speculate that this will lead to starvation just as surely as price caps. If that’s what you think, then you’re forgetting about the most fundamental piece of the free market puzzle: competition.
For the free market not only gives importers the freedom to charge whatever they want, but it also allows anyone (not just those approved by the government) to grow, transport, and sell apples. Let’s imagine you’re a farmer in a nearby region, and you find out that apples go for $10 each in a nearby area experiencing drought. What are you going to do? Start growing apples and transporting them over to the drought region in the largest quantities you can! This does not require you to be selfless or concerned with the welfare of the starving people. It is in your own self-interest to produce surplus food and get it into regions with food shortages. The beauty of the free market system is that it harnesses the self-interest of individuals and companies, and puts it to work helping others.
So now you - and all the other farmers in nearby regions - will be shipping in apples at a massive rate, to take advantage of the high price being offered. Of course once there is a flood of apples coming into the drought region due to the high profits to be made, what will happen? Importers selling the apples will lower their prices a little to compete with each other. One will sell for $9.50, thereby getting the drop on everyone else and selling more apples. Pretty soon the others will match and a price war will begin. The price will bottom out only when the importers hit a level where they can’t go any lower. They will probably end up someplace close to $1.50 - more than usual, since they are being imported at extra cost, but still only a little more than they cost when there was no drought.
With a truly free economy, mass starvation will never occur. With a centrally-controlled economy, it is almost guaranteed to happen sooner or later.