TV Show Recommendations from a TV Hater

Life by Adam on 2005-12-01 04:02

Looking back over my past few entries, it’s starting to seem like all I ever think about is economics. In fact that’s not the case at all, so let me break things up a little with something completely different: television.

I don’t watch tv, but I do watch tv shows. If that doesn’t make any sense to you then read this post. The cliff notes version is that I get no broadcast, cable, or satellite tv in my home, but I do get a steady stream of tv shows coming in through Netflix.

I’ve never watched a lot of tv, but Netflix has changed that. Besides the convenience of watching exactly when I want to, without any commercials or scheduling conflicts, I also get to watch the shows in order from the very first episode. I also never have the need or desire to watch anything more than once. (Reruns seem intensely lame now that I realize how many good shows there are to watch - more than enough to keep oneself occupied without re-watching things.)

In particular, the HBO and (to a lesser degree) Showtime shows are of particular interest. Since these shows are originally aired on channels which have no restrictions on language, sexual content, violence, etc, this opens up a whole new world of topics. It also has the effect of making “regular” tv shows seem a little bit one-dimensional. I mean really, who the fuck lives their entire life without ever using a single fucking curse word? Hardly anyone; certainly not the hard-boiled cops, teenagers, and other character types which are so common on tv.

Last of all, Netflix allows one to discover hidden gems - shows which never got a lot of attention, maybe only ran for a season (or even less).

So, without further ado, here is my list of unique, though-provoking, and entertaining tv shows that I recommend you get on DVD, or download with Bittorrent.

The Wire - Pure genius. Before watching this show, I always thought of tv shows as lame movies: shorter, smaller budget, weaker writing, worse acting. This one totally changed my perspective. The writing is incredible, with a carefully-crafted, mind-bogglingly detailed story arc stretching through the season. It is also probably the most realistic and believable show (or movie, for that matter) that I’ve ever seen.

All of this is even more astonishing when you consider that the show’s subject matter is exactly the sort of thing that I normally wouldn’t like at all: it’s a cop show about busting drug-dealing gangsters. In fact, I found it very difficult to watch the first few episodes due to the subject matter; but I pushed through and eventually came to appreciate it despite that.

(Interesting side note: watching this show has given me a pretty good comprehension of black slang / ebonics. I was astonished to learn that this is a perfectly effective and functional spoken language, rather than just “bad english” as I had previously assumed.)

I just can’t say enough good things about this show. If you do watch it, make sure you start from the very first episode and watch the entire season through in order.

Firefly - A year ago I would have called this the most underrated tv show ever made, but in a twist of fate not unlike that of the original Star Trek series, it has been given a new lease on life in the movie Serenity. First you should know that the show is created by Joss Whedon, the genius behind Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel, and also the writer for Toy Story and Titan A.E. This guy has a a completely unique style of writing (and especially humor) that sets his work apart from anything else on the small or the big screen. If you get bored with the formulaic writing that seems to plague most movies and tv, you’ll no doubt find his style a breath of fresh air.

The setting for the show is “cowboys in space,” but before you run away screaming allow me to assure you that this seemingly campy theme works remarkably well. Whedon’s down-to-earth characters, dialog, and humor make this way more believable than shows based on much less outrageous themes.

Firefly got canceled after a mere dozen episodes, so savor each one. Serenity is set after the end of the show, so if you haven’t seen it yet, wait until you’ve seen the entire show.

Farscape - Another case of “sci-fi shows that start with F and were canceled before their time.” Farscape is unique in its use of Jim Henson muppets for the numerous alien characters. This gives it a unique feel when compared to the more common approaches of “actors with bumpy foreheads” (i.e., Star Trek) or computer-generated characters (i.e., most any current sci-fi movie). Similar to Firefly, the main character copes with his situation (being stranded in outer space with a ship full of aliens) through humor, which is very human and believable. Compare this to the inhuman stiffness in the face of stress and danger which seem to be common in the characters show both in sci-fi and other genres.

Farscape was canceled after a few seasons, and without any warning at all - the show was extremely popular at the time, and the writers had no idea they needed to wrap up the story. As a result, everything was left hanging and much drama ensued. Fans railed through numerous internet sites and even a commercial; eventually the Sci-Fi channel (who created the show and owns the property) was convinced to make a miniseries which brought the story to a satisfying conclusion.

Freaks & Geeks - This show bucks the trend by being a show that starts with F and was canceled before its time but is not sci-fi. The premise of the show is watching a bunch of kids struggle with the trials of high school in the early 80’s. Normally this isn’t something I’d be into, but a few things make this one interesting. First is the central theme to which the title alludes: what it’s like to be an outcast from the mainstream culture of high school. Two groups in particular get the spotlight: freaks (aka burnouts, losers, stoners) and geeks (aka nerds, dorks, brainiacs). The main character starts as a geek but finds herself drawn to the world of the freaks and eventually straddles the divide. As someone who took the very same path in high school (and in the late 80’s, no less), this one strikes very close to home for me.

Perhaps the most effective part of the show’s delivery, though, is in how they portray the cool kids vs. the outcasts vs. parents vs. teachers. I remember how in high school it was so obvious who was cool, who wasn’t, and that adults (despite their good intentions) never had the slightest clue. This show portrays the teenager’s perspective perfectly.

Queer as Folk - If you’ve always wanted to mass quantities of gay sex but were too afraid to rent a homosexual porno, this is the show for you. Well, not quite, but sometimes it seems like it. This one follows the lives of a few people who are pretty unremarkable in most ways except one: their sexuality. In a time when same-sex relationships are rarely seen at all on tv, this show stands out for telling it like it is. Since this is a show about gay life and culture, that means spending quite a lot of time on sex. (Queer as Folk makes no bones about this. The first line of the first episode is, “It’s all about sex.”)

This show is important because it puts the (stereotypical, yes, but still quite accurate) gay lifestyle on display for the world to see. For southern California hippies like me who hang out in places like Hilcrest and West Hollywood this isn’t too shocking, but I suspect for much of America it is.

Of course I wouldn’t recommend it if that’s all the show was. It’s also witty, well-written, well-acted, and touches on many unique subjects about love and sex that are applicable to anyone regardless of their sexuality.

The L Word - One morning at Showtime headquarters, a clever executive came up with this bright idea: “People like our show about fags, why not one about dykes?” Thus, the L Word was born.

Well, I don’t have any proof of that. But it is essentially a companion show to Queer as Folk, documenting the lives of a group of lesbians who are pretty much unremarkable except for their sexuality. It’s a much younger show, with the second season having just finished as I write this. So far it’s not quite as strong of a show, especially in the writing department. (In particular, their unusual reliance on cameo celebrity appearances seems a little crutch-like.) Nevertheless it’s still pretty good, and did I mention it has lesbians? (Yes, there is nothing hotter than two women in a loving, committed relationship…)

Carnivale - The 1930’s dustbowl setting for this one is both unusual and highly evocative. Early on, each episode left me saying “Weird… doesn’t make any sense… but I like it.” It could have easily gone X-Files and never resolved into anything; but instead the far-out story actually starts to pull together. The first season ends with an incredible finale that, while not quite explaining everything, still left me very satisfied. The carnival setting offers plenty of room for myth, magic, and mystery, all of which is pulled off adroitly. This is quite possible the most unique tv show ever made, I can’t recommend it highly enough.

Six Feet Under - Now here’s an odd one: a show about a family-run funeral home. Surprisingly this makes for an engrossing and entertaining drama. I have to say that I think it was at its best toward the beginning; if you’re short on time I’d suggest just watching the first season only. The best part of the show was exploring the histories and personalities of the characters, and they had sort of used most of that up by the end of the first season.

24 - This one gets extra credit because, despite the fact it is not a Showtime or HBO show, it still manages to be extremely gritty and intense. The show follows a rebellious but heroic agent in a counter-terrorism agency; the twist is that everything on the show happens in real time. A season is 24 episodes covering a 24 hour period, and within each episode every minute that the show runs is a minute elapsed within the episode’s story. At first you would think this would be annoying: when a character says to someone else on the phone, “I’m on my way there, I’ll be there in twenty minutes,” it means you actually have to wait twenty minutes for the character to get in their car and drive where they are going. It actually works, though, and to great effect: the story twists and turns like mad, and it joins The Wire as one of the few shows which I am actually kept guessing. (I find most tv and movie storylines horribly predictable.)

Arrested Development - This is the only pure comedy on the list. The concept is a guy, Michael Bluth, who inherits the company housing development business when his father is sent to jail for corporate fraud. It turns out that his entire family is a corrupt (and altogether loony) bunch, and predictably, hilarity ensues. The real value of this show is the way it weaves together two or more seemingly unrelated story threads, sharing certain recurring elements between them to produce a unified theme for the episode. Although there is plenty of goofy, obvious humor, there is a strong undercurrent of clever triple-switchbacks and subtle references that make this show something special.

Unfortunately, this one jumped the shark rather early: the first season was dynamite from the very first episode, but the second season denigrated into base, sometimes outright slapstick, comedy without much of the subtlety present in the first season. It’s still somewhat entertaining, but no longer anything particularly special. I suppose it’s still possible they could turn things around in coming seasons. In the meantime I recommend only the first season.

Also of note is that this is a sitcom without a laugh track - I wouldn’t be willing to watch it otherwise. Laugh tracks are a gruesome abomination, and - in my not even slightly humble opinion - all shows that use them should be boycotted.

Samurai Jack - A cartoon by Genndy Tartakovsky, creator of Dexter’s Laboratory and the Powerpuff Girls, Samurai Jack is an eclectic mix of anime-style swordfighting action, humor, and epic myth-style storytelling set against a sci-fi backdrop. What I love about this show is its visual and audio design, which elevate it from a mere cartoon into true art. The use of sound is particularly notable - I’ve never seen anything quite like it, possibly at its best in episode 7, “The Three Blind Archers.” The show’s designers tap into numerous sources of mythology and classic fables, combining it with the far-future setting for a subtle, varied, and altogether pleasing effect. This one isn’t for everyone, but for those that can appreciate its subtleties it is a true gem.

Adult Swim - This collection of oddball cartoons is quite possibly the strangest tv you’re ever likely to glimpse. Among them, Aqua Teen Hunger Force, The Brak Show, Harvey Birdman, and Sealab 2021 stand out as favorites. Most of the Adult Swim shows are based on a concept which originated with Space Ghost Coast to Coast, which takes semi-obscure Hannah Barbara cartoon characters and juxtaposes them in outrageous situations. All of these shows are short (~12 minutes per episode) and in most cases, the first five or ten are the only ones that are any good. After that they just tend to run the original concept past its limit and just get weird to the point of being almost completely random. (Humor is a twist ending, something you weren’t expecting. When you cease expecting anything because the characters are constantly doing things that are completely random, there’s no potential for humor.)

Homestar Runner - Not a tv show, although you can get it on DVD. It deserves special mention because it is without a doubt the funniest cartoon ever made (and this is coming from a longtime Simpsons fan). The subtlety of the humor takes a while to pick up on, since most of it comes from the strange little world which is constructed through the numerous short clips available throughout the site (no single one is more than about six minutes long, and most are less than three). This site has singlehandedly converted me from grumbling about the existence of Flash to praising its name. (Sites that use Flash for any sort of navigation or textual content delivery still deserve a bullet between the eyes, however.)

Invader Zim - An evil, gothic, inept alien tries to invade the world, all the while marveling at the ugly, stupid, unwashed masses that are humanity. This thing was way too dark to be on Nickelodeon, which is probably why it got cancled pretty quickly. Created by Jhonen Vasquez, the twisted genius behind the comics books Johnny the Homicidal Maniac and Squee. I can honestly say that I really feel more Irken than human most of the time.

One comment per 'TV Show Recommendations from a TV Hater'

  1. Kat says:

    “Queer as Folk - If you’ve always wanted to mass quantities of gay sex but were too afraid to rent a homosexual porno, this is the show for you. Well, not quite, but sometimes it seems like it.”

    Odd you should describe the show that way, a friend of mine in Texas said pretty much the same thing when she watched it a couple months ago.

Post a comment

Enter your comment (some HTML allowed)