Reaching Your Audience
I am what most people would call a hard-core Libertarian.
I believe deeply in personal freedom, and especially building a society on
principles that work, instead of ideals that fail in the face of human nature.
I scoff as the federal government throws away money on social programs that
don’t work, and taxes the economy into recession.
I shake my head sadly at the liberals who assert that Big Government is
better at taking care of citizens than the citizens themselves; and I smirk at
conservatives who emphatically declare that the government should keep its nose
out of your business, unless of course that business happens to be your sex
life or your religion.
I have noticed a trend among Libertarian arguments — in literature,
speeches, or discussion at my local chapter — of failing to reach the audience
because, instead, they launch straight into the argument’s central point.
I respect this; Libertarians are, by nature, direct and honest people. We
want to get straight to the heart of the matter.
But this fails to take into account the subtle but important aspect of a
successful sales pitch: Connecting with your audience. As a result, the
arguments presented often fall on deaf ears.
To sell someone on your idea, you must first convince them of the validity
of the source. In other words, why should they listen to you? And the only way
you can do that is to convince them that you have something in common.
In terms of political or philosophical arguments, this means starting by
showing them that you share some feelings on a given subject. You present a
common starting point, a place where your mind and theirs are in sync. When
they are comfortable with that, then you launch into your argument.
Want a quick example? Go back and look at the top of this article.
Don’t start them on the defensive
I didn’t start by saying, “Libertarians don’t know how to argue, that’s why
no one listens to us!” — even though that’s my point. If I had done so, you
would have immediately felt defensive (”We do so know how to argue! We’re the
only ones that tell it like it is!”), and most likely would not have been
receptive to my point of view.
Instead, I laid groundwork by presenting a viewpoint that most of us can
relate to. Not until the sixth paragraph did I present my argument, by which
time you have (hopefully) come to accept that I am a credible source.
Members of my own political party are an easy audience to target. What about
talking to a staunch liberal, where there is seemingly no common ground? Should
you bend the truth to accomplish your end?
Of course not. There’s always common ground; it’s up to you to find it. Here
are some short examples. The orientation text comes first, and then bridges to
the argument with a “that’s why” statement.
- Pro-welfare liberal: “Every time I see a person homeless on the street, in
the cold with no roof over their head, I think about what we can do to reduce
poverty in this country. That’s why we need to move poverty relief programs out
of the hands of the government and into the hands of church and community
organizations, who get four times as much out of every dollar contributed than
does the federal government.” - Socialized healthcare: “Improving the quality of healthcare is an issue
for everyone, from newborn children up through our senior citizens. That’s why
I believe in our private-sector healthcare industry; it has produced the best
care in the world, because it generates capital that rewards brilliant doctors
and researchers, and provides the resources necessary for the development of
new drugs and surgical techniques to combat the diseases that we all worry
about.” - Anti-drug conservative: “Drug abuse is a horrible thing. Addiction is a
disease which hurts people, families, and communities. That’s why I want to end
the War on Drugs, because it’s making the drug abuse and addiction problem
worse by introducing a huge black market and forcing addicts to hide their
problem instead of seeking the help they need.” - Anti-private education: “We all want the very best education for our kids,
because they are our future. That’s why I support private schools over public:
They give a better, safer education, for less overall cost.” - Affirmative action supporter: “Minorities have faced a long, cruel
history in this country, and their struggles continue today. That’s why we
should eliminate affirmative action and other programs which segregate on the
basis of race. The black, Hispanic, and Asian peoples have the strength,
intelligence, and force of will to succeed without any crutches, despite all
the adversity they have faced in the past.”
Over-dramatic, maybe even sappy to those used to the cold, hard facts,
statistics, and analysis of Libertarian arguments. But I guarantee you that a
soft padding of emotion and human relevancy will create a more receptive
audience for our arguments.
And we all want that.
This article was originally published in the December 2003 issue of the LP News. Don’t worry though: I wrote it, so it’s not plagerism. You could, however, say that it is an entirely different kind of cheating to post an old work on my blog, as if it were a new entry.